Showing posts with label Mises. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mises. Show all posts

Thursday, May 12, 2022

Bureaucracy: The Lost Gem

  • I have written an article about one of my favorite Mises books Bureaucracy.  It is found in the book: A Companion to Ludwig von Mises, p
  • ublished by the Universidad Francisco Marroquin.  I hope that you enjoy reading it.

  • It was published in May 2020.  Here is a link to the chapter:

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/358672765_Bureaucracy_The_Lost_Gem

Wednesday, August 21, 2013

A Course in Free Markets

This year I was asked to put together a class that does not shy away from the virtues of the free market.  This Summer I was speaking at Clemson University for the Foundation for Economic Education (FEE) and I showed my course outline to Larry Reed, the President of FEE.  After looking at it, he not only liked it, but asked if I could make the outline widely available.  And so here it is, my economics course that argues that Free Markets are a good and moral system that creates good character and expands societal wealth and living standards.  I hope you like it and if you have any comments, please feel free to do so.

Tentative Course Outline:     

WEEK #1     Read Part I: “Non-Contradiction” of Atlas Shrugged
     Morality of Markets

1.                “The Economic Foundations of Freedom,” by Ludwig von Mises, in Economic Freedom and Interventionism: An Anthology of Articles and Essays, 1990, pp. 3-10.  Found here: http://mises.org/efandi/ch1.asp

2.                “Liberty and Dignity Explain the Modern World,” by Deirdre N. McCloskey, in The Morality of Capitalism, 2011, pp. 27-30.  Found here: http://atlasnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/downloads/2011/10/The-Morality-of-Capitalism-PDF.pdf

3.                “The Intellectual Defense of Liberty,” by Walter E. Williams, October 1, 2007.  Found here: http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/the-intellectual-defense-of-liberty#axzz2Rt0sMHqQ

WEEK #2

4.                Honesty and Trust,” by Walter E. Williams, February 1, 2005. Found here: http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/honesty-and-trust#axzz2Rt0sMHqQ

5.                “Competition and Cooperation,” by David Boaz, in The Morality of Capitalism, 2011, pp 31-36.  Found here: http://atlasnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/downloads/2011/10/The-Morality-of-Capitalism-PDF.pdf

6.                “Ayn Rand and Capitalism: The Moral Revolution,” by David Kelley, in The Morality of Capitalism, 2011, pp. 69-.  Found here: http://atlasnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/downloads/2011/10/The-Morality-of-Capitalism-PDF.pdf

7.                “The Elite Under Capitalism,” by Ludwig von Mises, in Economic Freedom and Interventionism: An Anthology of Articles and Essays, 1990, pp. 18-25.  Found here: http://mises.org/efandi/ch3.asp

8.                “The Market Economy and the Distribution of Wealth,” by Ludwig Lachmann, in The Morality of Capitalism, 2011, pp. 87-95.  Found here: http://atlasnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/downloads/2011/10/The-Morality-of-Capitalism-PDF.pdf

LABOR DAY September 2nd -- NO CLASS

WEEK #3
     Counter-Factual Reasoning

9.                 “The Lesson,” by Henry Hazlitt, Economics in One Lesson, 1946, Ch 1 pp. 3-7.   Found here: http://library.mises.org/books/Henry%20Hazlitt/Economics%20in%20One%20Lesson.pdf

10.             “The Broken Window,” by Henry Hazlitt, Economics in One Lesson, 1946, Ch 2 pp. 11-12.   Found here: http://library.mises.org/books/Henry%20Hazlitt/Economics%20in%20One%20Lesson.pdf

11.             “The Candlemakers’ Petition,” by Frederic Bastiat, in Economic Sophisms, part 1, 1845.  Found here: http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/the-candlemakers-petition#axzz2Rt0sMHqQ

12.             Bastiat “Something Else,” by Frederic Bastiat, in Economic Sophisms, part 2, 1848.  Found here: http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/something-else#axzz2Rt0sMHqQ

WEEK #4

13.             “I, Pencil,” by Leonard Read, 1958. Found here: http://www.fee.org/library/books/i-pencil/
     Methodological Individualism

14.             “The Individual in Society,” by Ludwig von Mises, excerpted from Human Action, 1966. Found here: http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/the-individual-in-society#axzz2Rt0sMHqQ

15.             “The Class Struggle,” by Ludwig von Mises, Theory and History, pp. 112-122.  Found here: http://mises.org/document/118/Theory-and-History

TEST #1  September 11th

WEEK #5                   Movie: Atlas Shrugged Part I

WEEK #6     Read Part II: “Either-Or” of Atlas Shrugged
     The Individual and Society

16.             The Law, by Frederic Bastiat, 1950, pages 1-9, 17-21, 24-29 and 63-64.  Found here: http://www.fee.org/files/doclib/20121116_TheLaw.pdf

17.             “Economics and Property Rights,” by Walter E. Williams, January 1, 2008.  Found here: http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/economics-and-property-rights#axzz2Rt0sMHqQ

18.             What Social Classes Owe to Each Other, William Graham Sumner, 1911, Chapters 1 & 2.  Found here: http://oll.libertyfund.org/index.php?option=com_staticxt&staticfile=show.php%3Ftitle=346&Itemid=99999999

WEEK #7                  
     Law of Association / Comparative Advantage

19.             Not a Zero-Sum Game by Manuel Ayau, 2007, Part 1, pp. 23-50.  Found here: http://library.mises.org/books/Manuel%20F%20Ayau/Not%20a%20Zero-Sum%20Game%20The%20Paradox%20of%20Exchange.pdf

WEEK #8                  
     Direct and Indirect Exchange: Supply and Demand

20.             The Mystery of Banking, by Murray Rothbard, 2008, Chapter 2 and Chapter 1. (Yes, read them in reverse order.)  Found here: http://www.mises.org/document/614/Mystery-of-Banking-The

WEEK #9                   MID-TERM  October 14th
     Profit & Loss

21.            “Profit Management,” by Ludwig von Mises, in Bureaucracy, 1962. Found here: http://www.mises.org/etexts/mises/bureaucracy/section1.asp

22.            “Bureaucratic Management,’ by Ludwig von Mises, in Bureaucracy, 1962. Found here: http://mises.org/etexts/mises/bureaucracy/section2.asp

WEEK #10

23.            “What Is Profit?” by Fred Foldvary, 2012.  Found here: http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/what-is-profit#axzz2Rt0sMHqQ
     Effects of Markets

24.            “The Economic Role of Savings and Capital Goods,” by Ludwig von Mises, in Economic Freedom and Interventionism: An Anthology of Articles and Essays, 1990, pp. 26-30.  Found here: http://mises.org/efandi/ch4.asp

25.            “Luxuries into Necessities,” by Ludwig von Mises, in Economic Freedom and Interventionism: An Anthology of Articles and Essays, 1990, pp. 31-32.  Found here: http://mises.org/efandi/ch5.asp

26.            “Political and Economic Freedoms Together Spawn Humanity’s Miracles,” by Temba Nolutshungu, in The Morality of Capitalism, 2011, pp. 96-99.  Found here: http://atlasnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/downloads/2011/10/The-Morality-of-Capitalism-PDF.pdf
     Critiques of the Welfare State

27.            “Middle-of-the-Road Policy Leads to Socialism,” by Ludwig von Mises, April 18, 1950.  Found here: http://mises.org/daily/2370

WEEK #11

28.            “Tragedy of the Welfare State,” by Tom G. Palmer, in After the Welfare State, 2012, pp. 5-14. Found here: http://studentsforliberty.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/After-the-Welfare-State-PDF.pdf


WEEK #12                 TEST #2  November 4th


WEEK #13                 Movie: Atlas Shrugged Part II

Read Part III: “A Is A” of Atlas Shrugged

29.            “The Welfare State as a Pyramid Scheme,” by Michael Tanner, in After the Welfare State, 2012, pp. 91-96. Found here: http://studentsforliberty.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/After-the-Welfare-State-PDF.pdf

WEEK #14

30.            “The Evolution of Mutual Aid,” by David Green, in After the Welfare State, 2012, pp. 55-65. Found here: http://studentsforliberty.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/After-the-Welfare-State-PDF.pdf

31.            “Mutual Aid for Social Welfare: The Case of American Fraternal Societies,” by David Beito, in After the Welfare State, 2012, pp. 67-88. Found here: http://studentsforliberty.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/After-the-Welfare-State-PDF.pdf
 

WEEK #15                 (finish #31)

THANKSGIVING November 27th – NO CLASS

WEEK #16

32.            “How the Right to ‘Affordable Housing’ Created the Bubble that Crashed the World Economy,” by Johan Norberg, in After the Welfare State, 2012, pp. 97-105. Found here: http://studentsforliberty.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/After-the-Welfare-State-PDF.pdf 

33.            “Greece as a Precautionary Tale,” by Aristides Hatzis, in After the Welfare State, 2012, pp. 21-30. Found here: http://studentsforliberty.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/After-the-Welfare-State-PDF.pdf

 

Monday, October 15, 2012

Teaching Austrian Economic Theory

This weekend I had the pleasure to speak before the 12th Annual Economics Teaching Workshop co-sponsored by UNC-Wilmington and Cengage Learning.  My topic was "Teaching Austrian Economic Theory."  The attendees were professors and instructors (with a few grad students thrown in for flavor).  I was happily surprised to see several hands go up when I asked how many have heard of Austrian Economics.  

When I was asked to give the talk, I was given a wide latitude about what I could say.  While having such discretion is a wonderful thing, I found that I had very little idea who my audience would be.  After thinking about it, I realized that I had to do the following:

  1. Introduce and explain what Austrian Economics is.
  2. Show how it differs with the mainstream.
  3. Show how to teach it.
  4. Show why it is better.
  5. Do it for enough topics to be relevant.  (I chose to cover value theory, capital theory and business cycle theory.)
  6. And do it all in under an hour!
To be certain I talked quickly.  I don't think that I went too fast, however I did promise to post the PowerPoint presentation of the talk so that they weren't scrambling to write down a bunch of stuff. To fulfill that promise here are the PowerPoint notes.

Once again, I would like to thank my hosts for the event.  In particular Rob Burrus and Pete Schuhmann of UNC-W and John Carey of Cengage.

Sunday, June 10, 2012

FEE--Introduction to Austrian Economics Summer Seminar 2012

For the week of June 4th – 9th, the Foundation for Economic Education (FEE) held the first seminar for the summer in Atlanta.  This is the 50th anniversary for FEE to host a summer seminar.  I am honored that this has been my 10th year to lecture to students for FEE.


This past week was an introduction to Austrian Economics.  Steve Horwitz and I suggested a schedule for this year and we are grateful that it was accepted without revision.  I am really pleased with how well the lectures were integrated.  I can’t really think of any particularly unique issue that we didn’t at least mention.  The lectures were videoed and FEE will be posting them later this summer.  When they come out, I will link to them on the left-side of this blog. (You can see some earlier lectures posted there now.)

I gave four lectures for FEE and participated in a roundtable discussion on the controversy between fractional reserve free banking and 100% reserve banking. 

My first lecture was “Menger and the Early Austrians.”  In it, I talk about four major contributions Menger made.  Since I covered issues of capital and interest in a later lecture, I focused on Böhm-Bawerk’s approach to value theory and his refutation of Marx.  Then, I walked through the books that Wieser wrote, with (of course) some analysis of each.  And I finished by covering some of the insights made by David Green, Philip Wicksteed, and William Smart.  The PowerPoint to the “Menger and the Early Austrians” lecture is found here.

The second lecture was “Praxeology, Supply and Demand.”  Here I began by comparing the methodology of the Austrians with the mainstream.  I presented the mainstream’s approach to methodology and critique it.  In contrast, I presented the Austrian methodology and build up the Laws of Demand and Supply from first principles.  We then built a model of the market.  I finished the lecture by comparing the manner in which the mainstream derives demand curves using indifference curve analysis.  The mainstream’s approach suggests that there is an income effect and a substitution effect for each price change.  The Austrians tend to think that policies that are derived from this thinking are equivalent to hocus-pocus.  The bottom-line is that when the mainstream derives demand curves in this fashion, they are comparing two levels of total utility and looking at the marginal rate of substitution.  When the Austrians derive demand curves, we are looking at the marginal utility derived from the next unit.  While both approaches use marginal analysis, they are not the same.  The PowerPoint to the “Praxeology, Supply and Demand" lecture is found here.

The third and fourth lectures really build upon each other.  The third was “Capital and Interest” and the fourth was “Business Cycles.”  In “Capital and Interest,” I criticize the mainstream’s approach of allowing objective factors to control the interest rate and also the notion that capital can be represented by a homogeneous pool.  In contrast, the Austrians hold that interest rates are determined by subjective time preference for both the supply of loanable funds (savings) and the demand for loanable funds (borrowing).  Furthermore, Austrians hold that capital is mostly complementary.  As a result, capital has a structure that cannot be ignored.  If we do so, we miss some significant aspects to economic theorizing.  The PowerPoint to the “Capital and Interest” lecture is found here.

The last lecture was on “Business Cycles.”  I began by developing Garrison’s three interlocking graph model.  It contains the Loanable Funds Market, the Production Possibilities Frontier Curve, and the Structure of Production.  We then walked through how the model works for various macroeconomic fluctuations and finished with working through the stages of the Austrian Theory of the Business Cycle.  The lecture finished with examining how the other modern macroeconomic theories explain the boom and bust of a business cycle.  The PowerPoint to the “Business Cycle” lecture is found here.

The last activity was a roundtable on 100% reserve banking vs. fractional reserve free market banking.  All four of the faculty participated in this discussion.  We started by first explaining why the current system of fiat banking with a Central Bank was a terrible system.  Then we explained how 100% reserve banking would work and then how fractional reserve free banking (with competitive note issuance) would work.  We then voiced our concerns about each system and then took questions from the students.  Since this was the last time we were talking before the group, we opened the last 15 minutes up to any question the students had on Austrian Economics.  There are no PowerPoint slides associated with this so I cannot link to anything right now.  However, when FEE posts it on the web, I’ll be sure to link to it.

I want to thank FEE for hosting another very good summer seminar.  The students asked some of the best quality questions we have heard for quite some time.  And the FEE staff did a marvelous job.  I appreciate the fact that the supporters of FEE have been able to keep this program going and also to be able to do it at such a high quality level.  Thanks!

Saturday, November 12, 2011

New Posts?

If you have noticed that there have not been any new posts in quite some time, you are correct.  It has been a busy time and I have fallen woefully behind. 

At the top of the distraction list is the birth of my third child (girl).  She is doing fine, but sleep has become something of a rare commodity in the household. 

Additionally, I have completely changed my approach to my Money and Banking class this semester.  I decided to use Rothbard's The Mystery of Banking as the primary text and the regular textbook as the secondary source.  I think that this experiment has been wildly successful.  The students are enjoying the class, and they are actually reading the book!  I asked one student if he managed to read Chapter 7.  He said that not only did he finish Chapter 7, but that he was reading ahead and was now starting Chapter 13!  It's even more amazing when its realized that we don't have economics majors at Mount Olive College!  The downside of all of this is that the class is a "new prep" and has been a major consumer of my time for most of this semester.

Anyway, the NCSU Austrian Readings Groups have still been continuing and I will write up and post the results of the discussions.  So there will be a #4, #5 and #6 to look forward to.

Next semester, we have agreed to open up the Readings Group.  The members of the group will get to pick a week and a topic, article, paper they are working on, etc. and present it to the group and lead the discussion.  I am looking forward to it.

As an aside, I recently finished reading Mises' Theory and History.  I have always been fearful of that book knowing that it's a book on methodology and that I could be quickly overwhelmed.  I could not have been more wrong.  In fact, I found the book very readable.  There were parts where one had to think about Mises' argument, but overall it was an enjoyable read.  I am somewhat ashamed of my earlier fears.  So note to self, never avoid reading Mises!

Friday, March 4, 2011

Austrian Economics Forum Spring 2011 #3--Non-Neutral Money

This session we had three readings: “The Non-Neutrality of Money” by Ludwig von Mises (1938 [1990]), “Neutrality of Money” by Don Patinkin (1987/1989) and “The Problem of Monetary Equilibrium,” by J.G. Koopmans (1936).  We started with Mises’ article and, sadly, ran out of time before we could really get into the Koopmans piece.  The Koopmans piece is a lecture that he gave at the LSE on June 15, 1936.  The copy we used comes from Professor Richard Ebeling.  He hopes that it will be soon published as a journal article.  We shall see.

The idea of money's non-neutrality seems to be fairly straight forward, while the idea of neutral money is the idea that seems to be alien.  Nevertheless if we examine the economics profession, the idea of non-neutral money is almost summarily rejected or, on a good day, it is given some lip service--and then tossed aside.  So what is neutral money and where does the idea come from?

In the mid-1700s, David Hume (Scottish philosopher and teacher of Adam Smith) was arguing against mercantilism.  Mercantilism was the political economic doctrine that held that a nation is richer if it has more gold and silver.  These riches could then be transformed into military power and then ultimately into national supremacy.  Hume argued that the wealth of a nation could not be simply measured by counting the amount of money (gold and silver) that existed in the economy.  He said that ultimately wealth was found in the goods and services in a country and not the amount of money.  For example, suppose that an economy doubles its money supply overnight.  Is it doubly as rich?  The obvious answer is, "No, all that changes is prices."

So far the neutral and the non-neutral money theorists agree.  The next step is where the two groups part company.

The neutral money theorist says that if the money supply doubles, then all prices will double.  The modern version of this position is that the "Price Level" doubles.  In other words, on average, prices will double. 

The non-neutral money theorist says that this analysis is drawing conclusions with assumed facts.  The neutral money supporter is implicitly assuming his conclusions: increasing the money supply has no effects on anything real. 

So let's get into the details of the debate.

First of all, the Austrian asks what is meant by the "Price Level"?  Mises explicitly rejects the metaphorical use of the term "level."  It conjures up an image of a pool of water in which water is added or withdrawn.  The height of the water in the pool then reflects the change in the injections--i.e., a doubling of the amount of water, doubles the height of the pool's level.  Money is not diffused into an economy so quickly.  Hayek has said that instead of water, we might envision the pouring of honey.  Mises argues that positing all prices and wages simultaneously rising or falling to the same extent simply cannot be assumed. 

Patinkin, on the other hand, argues that nothing other than exactly that can occur.  He sets up a general equilibrium model of an economy and then increases the money supply by "k."  He then shows, mathematically, that in order for all the equations to reequilibrate, all prices and wages must increase by exactly "k."  The assumption is made at the moment when we assume unique general equilibrium conditions.  If there is only one solution for general equilibrium, then of course the only solution is to change prices by "k."  However, that is a huge assumption that is never (rarely?) justified.  In his defense, Patinkin does admit that in the short-run there may be some non-neutral effects, however, his argument is that the long-run patterns must reemerge.

But, let's take Patinkin at face value.  The entire focus of Austrian analysis is on the short-run effects of monetary injections and their distortionary effects.  So, why should the Austrian even take the bait and argue the implications of a hypothetical long-run, which will never emerge?  Furthermore, as we will see below, the role of heterogeneous capital will make returning to an original hypothetical long-run equilibrium impossible.

So then what is the Austrian position and why is it so important?

The Austrians do not view money as some mystical numeraire that simply measures the height of purchasing power.  Instead, money is a good that is also subject to the same laws of diminishing marginal utility (demand) and increasing opportunity costs (supply) that govern all other goods and services.  Since the valuation of money is governed by marginal appraisals and the goods and services purchased are also governed by marginal appraisals, then the concepts such as "Price Level" and "velocity" must be viewed with extreme suspicion.  Indeed, Mises outrightly rejects the use of either.  Mises states,

Monetary problems are economic problems and have to be dealt with in the same way as all other economic problems.  The monetary economist does not have to deal with universal entities like volume of trade meaning total volume of trade or quantity of money meaning all the money current in the whole economic system.  Still less can he make use of the nebulous metaphor "velocity of circulation."  He has to realize that the demand for money arises from the preferences of individuals. ... Money is never simply in the economic system, ..., money is never simply circulating. ... The decisions of individuals regarding the magnitude of their cash holdings constitute the ultimate factor in the formulation of purchasing power.

As a result, it makes no sense to aggregate all of the money into a graph containing Money Supply and Money Demand to determine the "Purchasing Power" of money.  Furthermore, the Austrians reject the "equation of exchange," MV = PQ. 

So without such mechanisms for analysis, what is the proper method for examining macroeconomic and monetary problems?

The Austrians use a stepwise approach.  Austrians argue that money is injected into specific points into the economy and that these injection effects have specific impacts and implications.  Suppose that the central bank creates and injects new money into the economy.  Economists agree that this money creation favors debtors and harms creditors.  Additionally, economists agree that a signal extraction problem might emerge; that it is a hidden tax and can distort the incidence of the tax code; and that it can blossum into hyperinflation, which can be very difficult to reverse.  However, the Austrians focus on the emergence of the Cantillon Effects. 

If the central bank creates $100, it is injected into the economy and not scattered evenly throughout it.  As a result the first person (firm, institution, etc.) to get the new money has an advantage over everyone else.  He is able to obtain $100 worth of goods and services at today's prices without first contributing to the general welfare.  The buyer who uses this new money competes against everyone else in the economy.  The effect of his purchases is an increase in the demands for those specific goods, resulting in the prices for those goods inching up.  Now those who have the new money are able to buy goods and services with only some prices slightly higher.  The effect ripples through the economy.  As the new money passes from person-to-person, prices inch up as a real goods and services are exchanged. 

While this process continues there are those people who do not yet have the new money.  Nevertheless, the prices that they face are rising.  Their real wealth falls.  Thus, there is a real wealth transfer from those who get the new money last to those who got the new money first. 

The next step is to add heterogeneous capital to the analysis.  To the degree that capital has specificity, these distortionary effects create illiquid malinvestments.  As these malinvestments are built up in the economy, their removal becomes more difficult.  This idea is the underlying framework for Austrian Business Cycle Theory.

None of these issues emerge if money is assumed to be neutral.  Indeed, many economic problems become difficult to analyze when neutral money is assumed.  This is probably why Mises concludes his article with this important observation:

I wish to emphasize that in a living and changing world, in a world of action, there is no room left for a neutral money.  Money is non-neutral or it does not exist.

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Austrian Economics Forum Spring 2011 #2--Capital and Interest

At the end of the last post, a few questions were posed. Namely, "What are the necessary and sufficient conditions for the formation of interest rates?" "What determines the height of interest rates?" and "Can productivity influence the height of interest rates?"

The Clark/Knight position has been adopted by mainstream economists for several reasons.  At the top of the list is the point that homogeneous capital is easier to model than heterogeneous capital.  With homogeneous capital, the interest rate must equal the value marginal product of capital.  With this equality, we need only to look at what constitutes supply and demand in this market.

For the Clark/Knight position, there are two sides that need to come together to create an interest rate.  The first is the subjective side of time-preference.  Some people are natural born savers while others need to spend as soon as they get it into their hands.  Knight says that the demand side is the subjective, "time-preference" side.  (As an aside, Knight must be thinking of not the loanable funds market, but of the bond market.  Otherwise, his analysis on pages 421-422 is backwards.  So the demand for bonds, or the "desire to save money" is the time-preference side.)  The other side, the supply side, is the "'technical' side of the situation."  The supply of bonds, or the demand to borrow money, is based upon the objective productivity of capital.  Knight argues that this is the same analysis that is found "any elementary text-book," which shows "the relation between utility and cost."  He argues that there is no difference between the interest rate market and a goods market, where the supply of goods is objective and the demand for them is subjective.  He says that it is the same as the Marshallian scissors that create the market equilibrium price and quantity.

The Austrians have a different view of equilibrium, not only in the interest rate market, but in the regular goods and services markets as well.  On the demand side of any market, the mainstream and the Austrians agree that it is governed by subjective preferences.  In the (Knight's) bond market, it is time-preference, and in any goods market, it is subjective utility.  However, on the supply side of a goods market, Austrians argue that it, too, is governed by subjective preferences and not objective factors.  Of course, objective factors-like the amount available-do contribute to the final market price, but the core of the supply side of the market is still rooted in subjective utility. 

Let me explain.  From the Axiom of Human Action, we can deduce the Law of Diminishing Marginal Returns when we posit that we live in a world of scarcity.  Due to scarcity, we are forced to choose.  We choose according to our preference scale.  As we work down the scale, the marginal benefit of the next item picked must be less than the one above.  It is from the Law of Diminishing Marginal Returns that we deduce the demand curve. 

The derivation of the supply curve and the derivation of the demand curve have similar beginnings.  Again we recognize that we live in a world of scarcity and are forced to choose.  However, instead of starting at the top of the preference scale and working our way down, we work in reverse.  We start at the bottom and work our way up.  We ask what is the opportunity cost of the item that has the lowest utility.  Now if we lost that item, we ask what is the opportunity cost after that loss.  From this analysis, we derive the Law of Increasing Opportunity Costs.  It is from this law, that we are able to derive the Law of Supply and the supply curve.  Thus, both sides of the market are determined by subjective valuations. (For more on this see my lecture on Praxeology, Supply and Demand.)

So the Austrian position is that for goods markets, both demand and supply are subjectively determined.  It is not the meshing of the subjective on one hand and the objective on the other.  So, it should come as no surprise that the Austrians reject the Clark/Knight position that interest rates are created by the combination of subjective forces on one side and objective forces on the other.  Instead, Austrians have argued that Time Preference is the dominant force on both the demand and supply sides.

The title of this is the Pure Time-Preference Theory (PTPT) of interest rates.  This theory is not without criticism and does have some flaws that need to be worked out, but the general idea is that time-preference fulfills "the necessary and sufficient" requirements for interest rates to emerge.  The difficulty of this is found in the qualifying restriction of "ceteris paribus." 

What exactly is held constant and what is not?  During the discussion, one person argued against time-preference because there are certain things that he desired in the future, but did not want them now.  Rothbard uses the example of a person wanting breakfast at breakfast time (the future) and not in the evening (now).  And he also uses the example of a person who wants ice in the summer (the future) but not in the winter (now).  Rothbard argues that these examples violate the ceteris paribus restriction.  Not everything else has been held constant.  The person who doesn't want breakfast now, isn't hungry now.  However, he will be hungry in the morning.  What's changed?  Well, his appetite has changed.  Additionally, the person who doesn't want ice now is comparing to different seasons and thus not holding everything else constant.  What's changed?  The seasons have changed. 

All that time-preference is attempting to say is that people prefer sooner to later, holding everything else constant.  The trick is in holding all those other things constant.  Mises says that time-preference is a praxeological category of action.  In other words, its just how humans are built.  The debate over the finer points on this issue can be brought up at another time.

Austrians present the case that time-preference is not only a necessary condition for the formation of interest rates, it is also sufficient.  Money does not have to be present for the formation of interest rates.  Neither does exchange have to occur or even for there to be more than one person to have an interest rate govern intertemporal actions.


In Böhm-Bawerk's The Positive Theory of Capital (the second of three volumes on capital and interest), he states that the productivity of capital not only influences the height of interest rates, he argues that it is the most important factor.  Ingo Pellengahr (1996) argues that Böhm-Bawerk was not contradicting his earlier work.  (In the first volume he explicitly rejects the productivity theory of capital as the core of interest rates.)  Pellengahr states that Böhm-Bawerk was actually asking two separate questions.  In the first volume, Böhm-Bawerk was asking an essentialist question, "What is the origin and fundamental core of the formation of interest rates?"  In other words, he was examining the necessary and sufficient conditions for the formation of interest rates.  In the second volume, he changes his focus to a functionalist question of what influences the height of interest rates.  Several Austrians have agreed to this distinction.  However, this position of compromise is rejected by Fetter, Mises, Rothbard and Kirzner.

The Pure Time-Preference approach argues the case in this way...

First, we have to make a distinction between rents and interest return.  Every factor of production earns a return—a rent.  This return (rent) is the price that must be paid to a factor of production, which equals its marginal product.  Thus, every factor earns a rent that is equal to its marginal product.  Suppose that there is a machine that can produce a return of $10,000/year for 10 years.  Why is the price of this machine not $1,000,000 today?  The answer is that the future values need to be discounted back to the present.  Marginal productivity explains the height of the factor’s rental price.  However, it does not explain why these rents should be discounted across time.

Rothbard (1977 p.7) explains it this way, “Roundaboutness is an important aspect of the productivity of capital goods.  However, while this productivity may increase the rents to be derived from capital goods, it cannot account for an increase in the rate of interest return, that is, the ratio between the annual rents derived from these capital goods and their present price.  That ratio is strictly determined by time preference.” 

And so most Austrians reject the idea that changes in productivity and roundaboutness determine the height of interest rates.  Of course, we might want to qualify it by limiting the analysis to real interest rates in equilibrium, as opposed to nominal rates in disequilibrium.  Nevertheless, it seems that the debate amongst Austrians is more a definitional problem than that of an outright rejection of Böhm-Bawerk's analysis.

There is one last point to be made.  In the Kirzner article, he says that there does not exist a detailed criticism of Mises on Böhm-Bawerk's theory of capital and interest.  He is wrong.  Mises does critique Böhm-Bawerk in Nationalökonomie, pages 439-444.  That section has been translated into English and appears at the end of the book Mises Made Easier, by Percy and Bettina Bien Greaves, pages 150-157.

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Mises' "Latest" Book

Bettina Bien Greaves is a living treasure.  She has worked for decades at the Foundation for Economic Education (FEE) and attended just about every lecture that Mises gave at FEE and at NYU.  She would take shorthand notes of all that he said.  Today she is converting those notes back into text.  She has recently come out with a synthesis of several Mises lectures.  It is called: Ludwig von Mises on Money and Inflation: A Synthesis of Several Lectures.  You can find the book here and for sale here.

I am so excited about this that I am posting a short chapter below.  It is called, "The Constitutional Side of Inflation."  Enjoy...

When we talk about these things we must not forget that they do not have only an economic side; they also have a constitutional side. You may say that government is the most important institution. The government is very important in many regards. Perhaps one overrates the importance of the government, but one does not overrate the importance of good government.

Modern constitutions, the political systems of all nations that are not ruled by barbarian despots, are based upon the fact that the government depends financially upon the people, indirectly upon the men that the voters have elected for the constitutional assembly. And this system means that the government has no power to spend anything that has not been given it by the people, through the constitutional procedures which make it possible for the government to collect taxes. This is the fundamental political institution. And it is a fundamental political problem if the government can inflate. If the government has the power to print its own money, then this constitutional procedure becomes absolutely useless.

Our whole political system is based upon the fact that the voters are sovereign, that the voters are electing Congress and other such institutions in the various states that rule the country. We call the United States a democracy because the rule of the country is in the hands of the voters. The voters determine everything. And this distinguishes the system, not only from the despotic systems of other countries, but also from the conditions as they prevailed in earlier days, in countries that already had parliamentary institutions and parliamentary government, at that time. However, there has developed, especially in the last decade, a problem of  constitutional law, that is whether the government must get the approval of the people through Congress when it wants to spend, or whether the government, because it is established and has at its disposal a number of armed men, is free to spend as it wishes, simply by increasing the quantity of money. People must realize that the question is “Who should be supreme? The parliaments elected by the voters, who can restrict government spending by refusing to grant the power to tax? Or institutions that want to override the interests of the people by increasing the quantity of money to expand government spending and so do away with the prerogative and independence of the individual voter?”

If we do not succeed in restoring the monetary system that makes the individual independent to some extent of the interference of government institutions, government banks, government monetary authorities, government price ceilings, and so on, we will lose all the achievements of the free market and of the free initiative of the individuals, whatever methods of constitutional law we follow. If the government can inflate whenever it wants to spend, it can take away from the people without their agreement everything, their purchasing power, their savings, and so on. From this point of view there disappears even the fundamental principle which everybody sees as the difference between a Communist government and a government based on the idea of individual freedom, the preservation of free markets and the ability of the people to control the government.

If you look at the constitutional history of England in the 17th century, you learn that the Stuarts had problems with the British Parliament. The conflict consisted precisely in the fact that the Parliament was not prepared to give to the King of England the money he needed for purposes of which the Parliament didn’t approve. The people disapproved of a great part of the government expenditures and Parliament was not anxious to impose taxes. The Stuart kings wanted to spend more than Parliament was prepared to give them. If the King at that time, in 1630 let us say, had asked one of those who are considered experts today in government finance, “What can I do? I don’t have the money!” the “expert” would have said, “Unfortunately, your family, the Stuarts, came too early to their position as rulers. Two hundred years, three hundred years later, it would be much easier for such a government as you want to rule the country. A printing press would have been sufficient to make it possible for your government to spend all the money it needed to have an army and the other things needed to protect the King against the people.” But the poor Stuarts were living in an age in which the technique of producing paper money had not been developed to a considerable extent. Charles I couldn’t inflate, you know. There was no solution for him; he could not engage in deficit spending. This was the undoing of the Stuart family and the Stuart regime. And in the conflict which originated out of this, one member of the Stuart family lost his life in a very disagreeable way—Charles I lost his head. (fn1) And the Stuart family as such lost the crown of England. What the poor Stuarts didn’t have was the facility of the printing press as it exists today.

The monetary problem we have to struggle with today is the problem of paying for government expenditures which are not accepted or, let us say, not approved, by the people. The conduct of government affairs, public affairs, is not different from the conduct of the financial and monetary conduct of private affairs. If the government wants to spend, it has to collect the money; it must tax the people. If it doesn’t tax, but increases the quantity of money in order to spend more, then it brings about an inflation. The difference between the conditions in 18th century England and the conditions in other countries, let us say for instance in Russia, consisted of the fact that the Russian government was free to take away from its subjects what it wanted while the British government was not. The British government had to comply with the provisions of a set of laws that limited the amount of money the government had the right to collect from its citizens. And it had to spend this money precisely according to the wishes of the people.

All our constitutional laws and our system of government are based upon the fact the government is not permitted to do anything that violates this system of laws representing the moral and actual ideas and philosophies of our people. But if the government is in a position to increase the quantity of money, all these provisions become absolutely meaningless and useless. If it is said that the government has to spend, is entitled to spend, a definite amount of money for keeping people in prisons, this means something. There is a definite reason for its spending. All our legal provisions are influenced to some extent by the fact that this is the amount of money which is given to the government for this purpose. But if the government is in a position to increase the quantity of money to use for its own purposes, then all these things become merely a theoretical expression of something which has practically no meaning at all. We must not forget that all the protection given to individuals through constitutions and laws disappears if the government is in a position to  destroy the meaning of every inter-human relation by undermining the system of indirect exchange and money which is called the market. And this is much more importantthan any other problems we talk about today. It is the interference of the government with violence that has spoiled money, that has destroyed money in the past, and that is perhaps destroying it again today.

Some years ago you could frequently read quotations saying that Lenin said that the best method to destroy the free enterprise system would be to destroy the monetary system. Now a professor in Germany has demonstrated that Lenin never said this. But if Lenin had said this, it would have been the only correct thing that he ever said.

The monetary problem which we have in this country, which you have in every country today, is the same—to keep the budget in equilibrium, to balance income and outgo, revenue and expenditure without printing an additional quantity of banknotes, without increasing the quantity of the monetary units. This is not only a problem of economics. It is also the fundamental problem of constitutional government, you know.  Constitutional government is based upon the fact that the government can only spend what it has collected in taxes. And it can only tax the people if the people accept it by the vote of their representatives in parliament. And in this way the voters are the sovereigns. The problem of monetary management in a modern country cannot, therefore, be separated from the constitutional problem, from the doctrine that says that all problems of government, all governmental matters are decided ultimately by the vote of the people. Whether you call this democracy or popular government doesn’t make any difference. But there is no monetary or budgetary problem that can be separated from the constitutional problem of who rules the country, who determines ultimately what has to be done in the country.

Fn 1 Charles I was beheaded on January 30, 1649.